California prosecutors challenge Newsom’s death sentence commutations
The lawsuit argues Newsom acted unlawfully by proposing a blanket commutation without giving crime victims or their families the opportunity to be heard. The prosecutors say state law requires notice when condemned prisoners seek commutations, and contend the governor’s action cannot bypass those safeguards simply because it covers the entire death row population.
Prosecutors seek to block Newsom’s plan to commute death sentences
A coalition of prosecutors is asking California’s highest court to derail Newsom’s proposed commutations, arguing that victims’ rights procedures should apply even when clemency is independently proposed by the governor. The challenge puts the state’s death penalty system and the rights of victims’ families at the center of a fight over executive clemency.
Newsom’s position is that the notice requirements cited by prosecutors apply when a prisoner submits an application, not when the governor independently proposes clemency. He said his office would notify district attorneys after sending the proposals to the court and seek their help contacting victims and families.
The prosecutors’ lawsuit says that approach disregards the law and victims’ opportunity to be heard. The governor’s plan would commute sentences for 548 prisoners; nearly 400 cases require review by the state Supreme Court as the prisoners have convictions for several felonies.
No execution has taken place in California since 2006, and Newsom imposed an execution moratorium in 2019. The case will test whether prosecutors can use victims’ rights and procedural protections to halt a sweeping clemency proposal before the court completes its review.
Newsom’s mass clemency plan faces legal challenge from prosecutors
Newsom’s bid to commute every death sentence in California is facing a court challenge from prosecutors who say the governor cannot set aside victims’ rights and legally required procedures. The lawsuit asks the state Supreme Court to stop the plan, arguing that no governor is above the law.
The prosecutors contend that victims and their families must have an opportunity to be heard. Newsom says the notice rules do not apply because the commutations were initiated by him rather than requested by individual prisoners, and says his office would work with district attorneys on notifications after submitting the cases to the court.
The proposal covers 548 prisoners. Nearly 400 cases require Supreme Court review as the inmates have convictions for several felonies, and those commutations cannot take effect without the court’s approval. The challenge argues that deciding the outcome for the entire death row population in advance fails to give meaningful consideration to individual cases.
Newsom imposed a moratorium on executions in 2019, and California has not executed anyone since 2006. Prosecutors’ challenge now asks the court to determine whether his proposed clemency can proceed without the procedures they say protect victims and the rule of law.
Reported by CalMatters, New York Post.







