Judge Rejects DOJ Bid to Limit Prosecutor Testimony
U.S. District Judge April Perry denied a late-filed Justice Department motion seeking to narrow the testimony she has ordered from Chicago U.S. Attorney Andrew Boutros and three assistant U.S. attorneys. The inquiry concerns alleged misconduct during the prosecution of six people who protested President Donald Trump’s immigration crackdown in Chicago. The case fell apart in May.
The department’s motion, filed late on November 15, argued that only Boutros needed to provide information and directed all four prosecutors to assert legal privileges. It also asked Perry to delay the December 2 hearing if she ruled against the department, so it could seek reconsideration or appeal. Perry had rejected an earlier effort to limit her inquiry on November 11.
Perry said her questions would focus on facts, including whether communications took place, and that privilege would not shield the existence of a communication. The judge has said she is examining possible evasiveness, hiding important facts, or other wrongdoing before her. She has also said she will not ask questions that require privileged answers.
Lawyers for assistant prosecutors William Hogan, Matthew Skiba and Andres Almendarez said their clients do not intend to invoke the Fifth Amendment. Hogan’s lawyer also said he would not assert privileges. Boutros’s position was not stated at the hearing. Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward appeared for the department and questioned whether Perry should decide the privilege issue herself.
The four prosecutors are to submit proposed testimony for Perry’s review by November 20. The department may respond by November 25. The December 2 hearing could lead to sanctions or a criminal contempt finding, the judge has said.
DOJ Seeks to Shield Prosecutors as Judge Probes Case
A federal judge refused the Justice Department’s latest effort to restrict testimony about the collapse of the Broadview Six prosecution, keeping alive an inquiry into what prosecutors told the court. The case involved six people who protested President Donald Trump’s immigration crackdown in Chicago and fell apart in May.
Judge April Perry has ordered U.S. Attorney Andrew Boutros and three assistant prosecutors to testify on December 2 about alleged misconduct. The department’s late-November 15 motion sought to excuse the three line prosecutors and have all four witnesses assert legal privileges. It also asked for a delay if Perry rejected its position.
Perry said she would ask factual questions, including whether communications occurred, and that privilege would not conceal the fact that a communication existed. That matters because an assistant prosecutor had previously told the judge there had been no outside communications about investigative or charging decisions, including with the White House.
Lawyers for William Hogan, Matthew Skiba and Andres Almendarez said the three would not invoke the Fifth Amendment. Hogan’s attorney said he did not plan to assert privileges. Boutros’s position remains unstated. Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward argued that the executive branch should address the privilege question and raised the prospect of an appeal; Perry rejected the department’s bid to limit her inquiry.
The prosecutors must send proposed testimony to Perry by November 20, with the department allowed to respond by November 25. The December 2 hearing could bring sanctions or a criminal contempt finding. The judge’s insistence on examining the record leaves the department facing scrutiny rather than allowing its own privilege claims to close the matter.
Judge Rejects DOJ Effort to Set Limits on Testimony
A judge has rejected the Justice Department’s attempt to narrow what Chicago prosecutors may be required to say about a failed case, despite the department’s claim that legal privileges should restrict the inquiry. The case involved six protesters opposing President Donald Trump’s immigration crackdown in Chicago and collapsed in May.
Judge April Perry has ordered U.S. Attorney Andrew Boutros and three assistant U.S. attorneys to testify on December 2 about alleged misconduct before the court. The department’s motion, filed late on November 15, argued that Boutros alone should provide information and instructed all four witnesses to claim privileges. It also sought a delay to pursue reconsideration or an appeal if Perry ruled against it.
Perry said her questions would be factual and would not require privileged answers. She maintained that privilege cannot hide whether a communication happened. That approach could compel testimony about contacts while leaving disputes over protected content for the judge to assess.
Lawyers for William Hogan, Matthew Skiba and Andres Almendarez said the three would not take the Fifth Amendment. Hogan’s attorney said he did not intend to invoke privileges, while Boutros’s position was not stated. Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward challenged Perry’s role in deciding the issue and suggested the department could seek appellate relief. Perry denied the department’s motion.
The four prosecutors are to provide proposed testimony to Perry by November 20, and the department may respond by November 25. The judge has said the hearing could result in sanctions or criminal contempt. The privilege dispute is not resolved, but the department has not succeeded in stopping the court from preparing to hear the witnesses.
Reported by Raw Story, Chicago Sun-Times.






