Trump Urges Courts to Block Newsom’s Death Sentence Commutations
Trump criticized Newsom’s clemency plan in a Truth Social post on November 14, calling it a “disaster for Justice in America” and arguing that it ignored victims’ families and obstructed the legal proceedings. He said he hoped the decision would be overturned. Trump referred to 563 people on death row, while Newsom’s plan covers 548.
Newsom announced the plan on November 5. It would change the sentences of 529 men and 19 women to life in prison without the possibility of parole. No one would be released or become eligible for parole, and convictions and restitution orders would remain in place. The plan would go beyond Newsom’s 2019 moratorium, which paused executions but left death sentences intact.
The commutations have not taken effect. California’s Constitution requires a recommendation from at least four state Supreme Court justices before the governor can grant clemency to a person with multiple felony convictions; that applies to 382 people in the plan. Newsom wants the court to rule before the year ends, ahead of his January departure from office.
Victims’ relatives hold differing views on the plan. The Criminal Justice Legal Foundation, joined by prosecutors and relatives of victims, has said it intends to pursue legal challenges. Los Angeles County District Attorney Nathan Hochman also said his office would help challenge the commutations, arguing they sideline victims’ families and disregard the decisions of voters, juries and judges.
Newsom’s Plan Keeps Death Row Inmates Imprisoned for Life
Newsom’s plan would end death sentences for 548 people without releasing anyone or making anyone eligible for parole. Their criminal judgments and restitution requirements would stay as they are, and the sentences would become life without parole. Trump attacked the plan on November 14 and urged that it be overturned, citing 563 people—a different figure from the 548 covered by Newsom’s proposal.
The proposal goes beyond Newsom’s 2019 execution moratorium, which stopped executions while leaving death sentences in place. Newsom characterized life without parole as the harshest penalty the state can lawfully impose and ethically enforce, saying the offenders would die in prison. Prosecutors would still be able to seek the death penalty in future cases.
The plan has yet to clear required legal steps. For 382 people with more than one felony conviction, the California Constitution requires a recommendation from at least four state Supreme Court justices. Newsom wants the court to rule before the year ends, ahead of his January departure from office.
Some victims’ relatives favor abolishing death sentences, while others oppose the plan. The Criminal Justice Legal Foundation and prosecutors say they will pursue legal challenges, and Los Angeles County District Attorney Nathan Hochman says his office will help. Their challenge puts the focus on the families’ differing views and on whether the commutations can proceed through California’s legal process.
Newsom’s Blanket Death Sentence Commutations Face Legal Fight
Trump condemned Newsom’s plan to replace 548 death sentences with life without parole, saying on November 14 that it disregards victims’ families and halts the legal proceedings. He called the move a disaster for justice and said he hoped it would be overturned. Trump cited 563 people on death row, while Newsom’s plan covers 548.
The Criminal Justice Legal Foundation and prosecutors have said they will pursue legal challenges. Los Angeles County District Attorney Nathan Hochman says his office will join them, arguing that the blanket commutation sidelines victims’ families and disregards decisions by California voters, juries and judges. Victims’ relatives are divided, with some favoring the abolition of death sentences and others opposing it.
Newsom’s proposal would leave convictions and restitution orders intact and would not release anyone or make anyone eligible for parole. But it would replace death sentences with life imprisonment without parole, going further than the execution moratorium he imposed in 2019. Prosecutors could still seek capital punishment in future cases.
The commutations are not yet in effect. The California Constitution requires recommendations from at least four state Supreme Court justices for people with more than one felony conviction, a rule that applies to 382 of the 548. Newsom wants the court to rule before the year ends, ahead of his January departure from office. The legal challenge will test whether his plan can proceed despite the objections of prosecutors and some victims’ families.
Reported by Raw Story, Newsweek, New York Post, Daily Mail US, The Daily Beast, Townhall.








