Murder Victims’ Families Back Newsom’s Death Row Commutations
On November 9, families representing 50 people killed in California asked the state’s highest court to accept Gov. Gavin Newsom’s proposal to replace every death sentence with life without parole. The relatives also sent Newsom a letter asking him to carry out the proposal, which he announced the previous week.
California has 548 people on death row. Commutations for 382 of them require approval from a majority of the Supreme Court’s seven justices because those inmates have two earlier felony convictions.
The families said their opposition to executions persists despite the pain of losing loved ones. Jess Nichol, whose sister Polly Klaas was taken and killed at age 12 in Petaluma, said execution would not undo the killing or honor her sister. Paul Wilson, whose wife Christy was among eight people killed in a 2011 Seal Beach shooting, said commutation does not erase the crime or require victims’ families to forgive.
The families also asked Newsom to direct $150 million saved by ending expensive capital cases toward trauma recovery centers and flexible survivor support.
The proposal has drawn opposition from other victims’ relatives, police chiefs, police unions and district attorneys. Marc Klaas, Polly’s father, opposes commuting the sentence of her killer. California has carried out no execution in two decades.
Victims’ Families Say California Can Reject Executions Without Forgetting
On November 9, relatives of 50 people murdered in California called on the state’s top court to accept Gov. Gavin Newsom’s plan to replace all death sentences with life without parole. Their message challenges the claim that justice for victims depends on state executions.
California has 548 people on death row, and 382 commutations require approval by a majority of the Supreme Court’s seven justices since those inmates each have two earlier felony convictions. Newsom announced his plan the previous week.
The families said grief has not changed their moral opposition to capital punishment. Jess Nichol, whose sister, Polly Klaas, was taken and killed at age 12 in Petaluma, said killing her sister’s murderer would not repair the harm. Paul Wilson, whose wife Christy was among eight people killed in a 2011 Seal Beach shooting, said commutation neither erases the crime nor demands forgiveness.
The families are also asking Newsom to channel $150 million saved by ending expensive capital cases toward trauma recovery centers and adaptable support for survivors. Their position puts support for victims’ needs ahead of a punishment that, they say, cannot reverse their loss.
Other relatives, police chiefs, police unions and district attorneys oppose the plan. Marc Klaas, Polly’s father, strongly objects to commuting his daughter’s killer’s sentence. California has carried out no execution in two decades.
Newsom’s Death Row Plan Faces Opposition From Victims’ Families
On November 9, relatives representing 50 murder victims urged California’s highest court to approve Gov. Gavin Newsom’s plan to commute every death sentence. Their support does not erase the sharp disagreement among victims’ families over whether the state should preserve those sentences.
There are 548 people on California’s death row. For 382 inmates, the proposed commutations require approval from a majority of the court’s seven justices because they have two prior felony convictions. Newsom announced the plan the previous week.
The supporters say their opposition to the death penalty comes despite, not because of an absence of, pain. Jess Nichol, whose sister, Polly Klaas, was taken and killed at age 12 in Petaluma, said execution would not undo her sister’s killing. Paul Wilson, whose wife Christy was one of eight people killed in a 2011 Seal Beach shooting, said commutation does not erase the crime or require forgiveness.
The families are asking Newsom to redirect $150 million saved by ending expensive capital cases toward trauma recovery centers and adaptable assistance for survivors. But other families reject that approach: Polly’s father, Marc Klaas, is especially opposed to commuting the sentence of her killer. Police chiefs, police unions and district attorneys have also criticized the proposal.
No prisoner has been executed in California in two decades. The Supreme Court’s approval is needed for 382 of the planned commutations.
Reported by ABC7 Los Angeles, KTVU FOX 2, CNN.








