Newsom’s Death Sentence Decision Divides Polly Klaas’s Family
California Gov. Gavin Newsom’s plan to commute death sentences has drawn opposing responses from the family of Polly Klaas, who was kidnapped and murdered in Petaluma in 1993 when she was 12. Her father, Marc Klaas, called the decision heartbreaking; her sisters support it.
Klaas’s Sisters Back Ending Death Sentences in California
California can refuse to extend state killing in the name of victims, Polly Klaas’s sisters say, and they support Gov. Gavin Newsom’s plan to commute death sentences. Polly was kidnapped and murdered in Petaluma in 1993, at age 12. Her killer, Richard Allen Davis, received a death sentence.
Jess Nichol said she once wanted Davis executed, but years of healing and reflection changed her view. The death penalty, she said, would not undo Polly’s murder. She also argued that victims’ families disagree about executions, so death should not be the automatic answer.
Annie Nichol said the sentence had kept her family tied for decades to hearings, appeals and the prospect of another death, without bringing closure or helping them heal. The sisters are among families supporting Newsom’s decision. They and the group Clemency California are urging the state Supreme Court to approve it quickly. Their letter also asks California to shift $150 million in death-penalty spending toward trauma counseling facilities and adaptable aid for survivors.
Marc Klaas opposes the plan, saying Newsom acted without listening to Californians and harmed murder victims’ families. The sisters’ position makes a different case: the state should not compound violence in victims’ names. The court’s approval is needed for the commutations to take effect; one account says 382 inmates’ sentences would become life without parole if approved.
Newsom’s Death Penalty Move Ignores Victims, Klaas’s Father Says
A governor should not override Californians’ expressed support for capital punishment, Marc Klaas says, condemning Gavin Newsom’s plan to commute death sentences as heartbreaking. Klaas, whose 12-year-old daughter Polly was kidnapped and murdered in Petaluma in 1993, argued that the decision disregarded the public and the families left by such crimes.
Klaas said Californians had rejected ballot measures seeking to eliminate the death penalty. He described Newsom’s move as one made without listening to residents and said it struck a blow against murder victims’ families. He also invoked Polly’s killing and other notorious murders, arguing that the cases represented on death row involve grave crimes.
The plan has support from Polly’s sisters, who say execution would not undo her murder or bring their family closure. Jess Nichol said she once favored the death penalty for Davis, who was sentenced to death, but later came to oppose it. Annie Nichol said decades of hearings and appeals had not helped the family heal.
The divide within Polly’s family underscores the dispute over whether the death penalty serves victims and the public. The sisters and Clemency California are asking the state Supreme Court to approve Newsom’s request promptly. They also want $150 million redirected away from capital punishment expenses toward trauma counseling facilities and survivor assistance. One account says 382 inmates would receive life without parole if the court approves the decision.
Reported by Breitbart, ABC7 San Francisco.







