Close ✕
Crime U.S.
Photo: The Washington Examiner

Supreme Court Declines Challenge to California Bias Training Requirement

The Supreme Court declined to review a challenge by California doctors who say the state’s implicit-bias training requirement violates instructors’ First Amendment rights. Justices Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito and Neil Gorsuch favored hearing the case, but the court did not take it up; four votes were needed to do so.

California mandates 50 hours of recognized medical study for licensed physicians in each two-year period. Under a 2019 law, qualifying courses involving patient care must teach about unconscious prejudice and how it can affect patients’ health.

The challengers argued that requiring instructors to address the subject compels private speech. The Ninth Circuit treated the instruction as government speech, rather than private expression protected by the First Amendment. Thomas said that approach wrongly blurred the distinction between government expression and speech by private people operating under regulation. He also urged the court to reconsider its test for identifying government speech.

The court’s refusal to hear the case does not decide whether California’s requirement is constitutional. It leaves the Ninth Circuit’s judgment intact, and the state’s continuing-education rules remain in effect. Thomas’s dissent raises the possibility that the court could revisit its approach in a future case.

Reported by The Washington Examiner, Newsweek.

Related stories

Top stories now

About