Supreme Court Leaves Research Grant Ruling Against Trump in Place
The Supreme Court on November 16 rejected the Trump administration’s challenge to lower-court rulings over federal research grants to University of California researchers. The decision leaves those rulings in place and allows the cases to continue in federal district court, where the administration has been ordered to fund the grants at issue.
The grants came from two federal agencies: NSF and the humanities endowment. About $150 million was at issue in the Supreme Court appeal; the administration had sought to terminate $324 million in awards for University of California campuses as part of a wider effort to end grants it considered inconsistent with President Donald Trump’s policies.
Researchers argued that the cancellations targeted their viewpoints, including through searches for terms such as “diversity” and “climate change.” A federal judge and a Ninth Circuit appeals panel found that the terminations likely violated the First Amendment. The administration argued that it was changing funding priorities and that declining to fund research promoting DEI did not violate free-speech rights.
The high court gave no explanation for declining the appeal, and no justice publicly dissented. The appeals court separately said researchers seeking repayment of lost funding would need to bring a different case in the Court of Federal Claims. The Supreme Court’s decision leaves the grant cases in district court, which can order funding restored while litigation proceeds.
Supreme Court Blocks Trump’s Attempt to Punish Research Over DEI
The Supreme Court has left standing rulings that protect University of California researchers from the Trump administration’s effort to cancel grants tied to work touching on diversity, equity and inclusion. By refusing to hear the appeal on November 16, the justices kept the cases in federal district court and left in place an order requiring funding for the grants at issue.
Around $150 million in awards from NSF and the humanities endowment was at stake in the appeal. The administration had sought to end $324 million in financial support for University of California campuses as it pushed to align federal awards with President Donald Trump’s policy priorities.
Researchers said the grant cancellations discriminated against them for their views, including through searches for words such as “diversity” and “climate change.” Lower courts found the terminations likely violated the First Amendment. The administration maintained that it was simply changing federal funding priorities and that the Constitution does not require it to fund research promoting DEI.
The court issued no explanation and no dissents. Its refusal to intervene leaves in force a path through district court, where judges can order funds restored as cases proceed. A separate appeals-court ruling says researchers seeking repayment of money already lost must pursue a distinct case in the Court of Federal Claims. The administration’s claim of ordinary priority-setting did not persuade the lower courts that viewpoint-based grant cancellations were permissible.
Supreme Court Leaves Trump’s Grant Priorities Bound by Lower-Court Ruling
The Supreme Court declined on November 16 to review a challenge to the Trump administration’s authority to redirect federal research funding, leaving in place lower-court rulings that the grant cancellations likely violated the First Amendment. The result keeps the disputes in federal district court and leaves standing an order requiring funding for the grants at issue.
The administration argued that it was revising funding priorities, not violating free-speech rights. Its position was that the government need not award competitive grants to research projects promoting DEI. The awards, provided by NSF and the humanities endowment, involved about $150 million in the Supreme Court appeal.
Researchers countered that the cancellations targeted their viewpoints, pointing to searches for terms including “diversity” and “climate change.” A federal judge and a Ninth Circuit appeals panel sided with them, finding the terminations likely unconstitutional. The administration’s appeal sought to overturn that result, but the justices declined to take it up without explanation; there were no dissents.
The ruling leaves the administration’s funding decisions constrained by the lower courts’ First Amendment analysis while these cases continue. The appeals court separately said researchers seeking recovery of lost funds must file a different case in the Court of Federal Claims. The Supreme Court’s refusal to intervene means the administration’s argument for shifting grant priorities did not dislodge the district-court route or the funding order.







