Herbstreit Feeds Steak to His Dog at New York Restaurant

Kirk Herbstreit’s video of his golden retriever eating steak at a New York City restaurant drew criticism from broadcaster Craig Carton on November 13. Herbstreit, an ESPN college football analyst, posted footage of himself cutting steak into pieces and serving it to Peter on a plate on the floor. The dog finished the serving quickly, while Herbstreit said he wished Peter would take his time.

Carton objected to dogs being present at steakhouses, saying diners should be able to enjoy a meal without sitting next to one. He also criticized Herbstreit for filming the moment and turning it into social media content.

The video prompted contrasting reactions online. Some commenters defended sharing food with dogs and said Peter appeared well behaved; others argued the criticism was misplaced and that Herbstreit’s choices were his own.

Herbstreit has traveled with Peter for several years. His previous dog and travel companion, Ben, died in November 2024. The restaurant was not identified in the accounts of the incident.