Alaska Ballot Ruling Leaves Senate Count—and Key Questions—Open
An Alaska judge has rejected Democratic Senate candidate Mary Peltola’s campaign request for records identifying absentee ballots that election officials rejected and explaining why. The decision resolves a dispute over access to election information, not the Alaska Senate race itself. With ballots still being counted, Peltola held a narrow first-choice lead over Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan, and the state’s ranked-choice process was still set to determine the final result if no candidate passed 50 percent.
On Wednesday, Superior Court Judge Thomas Matthews said officials did not have to produce the requested information during the current count. His central concern was practical: the Division of Elections was already handling ballots from the general election and could not reasonably generate and review the customized report on the campaign’s timetable. Matthews also said officials could not reasonably remove confidential details in time. He described the timing as especially poor, while emphasizing at the hearing that the case concerned records access, not which candidate would win.
The campaign sued state election officials last Friday, seeking the list and rejection reasons. Its stated purpose was to help ensure that qualified voters’ ballots were counted. Campaign counsel told the court that the campaign saw no sign that the review process had gone badly and did not intend to disrupt it. The campaign’s argument was that making the information available in one place would provide a more centralized form of transparency, similar to what campaign observers could see at regional review boards. The lawsuit over rejected-ballot records set up that dispute.
The state countered that the requested reports were not public records and contained private information. Officials said they did not design the daily working documents for preservation or distribution. The version available to observers contains less sensitive material, but still includes voters’ home addresses, according to an election official’s affidavit. Observers sign confidentiality agreements and cannot keep or record the information. State lawyers also argued that preparing a separate report would consume staff time during a demanding phase of election administration. The judge’s earlier consideration of the case reflected the tension between transparency and the state’s operational and privacy concerns.
The ruling does not mean officials will skip review of rejected ballots, nor does it settle whether any particular ballot should count. Alaska’s absentee review boards meet at regional election offices, where campaign and party observers may watch. State law also allows challenges when there is good reason to suspect a voter is ineligible. The campaign said its request was meant to support the counting of eligible votes; the state said disclosing the requested records could expose information voters expect to remain private. The court’s decision was about whether officials had to produce this specific information under these circumstances.
The larger contest remains close. In the latest reported count, with about 86 percent of the expected vote tallied and more than 248,000 ballots counted, Peltola had 121,487 first-choice votes, or 48.9 percent, to Sullivan’s 117,512, or 47.3 percent. Her advantage was 3,975 votes. Those figures are provisional, and neither leading candidate had reached a majority. Alaska uses ranked-choice voting in its 2026 Senate election, with Sullivan seeking another term and Peltola challenging him. The state’s election rules and candidates provide the framework for what happens after first choices are counted.
The remaining candidates could matter when officials eliminate lower-ranked contenders and redistribute their voters’ next preferences. Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. had 4,100 votes and Gerald Heikes had 5,426 in the reported tally—both totals larger than the gap between the two leaders. That does not establish how those voters marked their next choices, but it explains why the first-place margin alone cannot settle the race. The state accepts ballots from overseas voters through November 18; officials were targeting that date for ranked-choice tabulation if no one wins a majority of first-choice votes. Officials expected certification on November 25. The question of when the result will be known therefore remains tied to the count and tabulation schedule.
Voters were also weighing whether to repeal Alaska’s ranked-choice system. The reported tally showed the measure failing, 52.5 percent to 47.5 percent, though election officials still could not call its outcome or the Senate contest. Ranked-choice voting is not an abstract side issue here: it sets the method for deciding the Senate race if no candidate receives more than half of the initial votes. Alaska also held a House election in 2024, alongside the presidential election and other contests, but the material available here does not establish a direct connection between that race and the current ballot dispute. The 2024 House election record offers only that broader electoral context.
For my part, I find the dispute understandable on both sides: voters deserve confidence that officials handle their ballots fairly, and they deserve protection from casual exposure of their private information. The immediate question is whether officials can finish the count and explain the process clearly. The judge’s order leaves the campaign without the centralized records it sought, while the count—and the work of earning public trust—continues.
Reported by The Philadelphia Inquirer, The Washington Examiner, Newsweek, Fox News, The Daily Caller.








