Measles Outbreak Shakes a Pennsylvania Midwife’s Vaccine Views
Roberta Devers, a traditional midwife in Lancaster County, says she has looked after many pregnant women with measles since the virus began spreading rapidly in the area in April. After years of questioning vaccines, she says seeing the illness affect families she serves changed her view. Pennsylvania reported 97 measles infections among pregnant women as of Wednesday; officials said they do not have figures for measles-related miscarriages.
Devers described one client who lost a pregnancy after becoming ill at 17 weeks. Measles during pregnancy can lead to complications including miscarriage and preterm birth. Pregnant women cannot receive the MMR vaccine because it contains a weakened live virus. Devers can advise families about isolation and infection risks, but state law does not allow traditional midwives to administer vaccines. Licensed nurse midwives can give them.
Vaccination rates have fallen in Lancaster County. MMR coverage among kindergartners was 87.6% last school year, down from 95.5% before the pandemic. A 2022 survey found that 30% of Amish families surveyed vaccinated their children, compared with 52% in 2014. Across the country, 75% of counties and jurisdictions with available data were below the measles herd-immunity threshold at the start of the 2025-26 school year.
Pennsylvania had recorded 1,505 measles cases as of Wednesday, with more than a third in Lancaster County. The state said it had administered nearly 11,000 MMR vaccinations during 2026. Traditional midwives have asked to be allowed to carry the vaccine, but the health department says a change would require action by the Legislature.
Some doctors have argued that natural measles infection in childhood may provide mothers stronger protection for their babies than vaccination. The American Academy of Pediatrics says congenital measles was uncommon before vaccination, when most pregnant women had been infected in childhood. It estimates that 25% to 30% of pregnant women who contract measles pass the virus to the fetus.
Falling Vaccination Rates Leave Pennsylvania Families Exposed
Measles is reaching pregnant women and families in Lancaster County as vaccination coverage declines. Roberta Devers, a traditional midwife who once chose not to vaccinate her son, says caring for infected clients changed her outlook: the consequences became real in the families she serves.
Pennsylvania reported measles in 97 pregnant women as of Wednesday, and the state had recorded 1,505 cases overall, more than a third in Lancaster County. Devers described a client who lost a pregnancy at 17 weeks after contracting measles. The illness can increase the risks of miscarriage and preterm birth, while pregnant women cannot receive the live-virus MMR vaccine.
The county’s kindergarten MMR rate fell from 95.5% before the pandemic to 87.6% last school year. Nationwide, 75% of counties and jurisdictions with data were below the measles herd-immunity threshold at the start of the 2025-26 school year. The figures show the stakes of allowing vaccine coverage to erode: outbreaks can reach people, including pregnant women, who cannot take the vaccine.
Devers can counsel families on isolation but is barred from administering vaccines. The health department says traditional midwives would need legislative authorization; licensed nurse midwives can give shots, and the state says it has administered nearly 11,000 MMR doses this year. Doctors who argue that natural infection offers mothers and babies better protection point to historical rarity of congenital measles, but the American Academy of Pediatrics says that rarity reflected the fact that most women had already been infected as children.
Midwife’s Measles Experience Fuels New Questions About Vaccine Policy
Roberta Devers says the measles outbreak has changed her thinking about vaccines, but the policy response raises a practical question: why can’t a trusted traditional midwife carry the shots families are asking for? Devers says pregnant women and unvaccinated husbands have called her for help, yet state law prevents her from administering vaccines.
Pennsylvania officials say traditional midwives cannot be authorized to give vaccines without a change in state law. Licensed nurse midwives can administer MMR shots, and the state says it has given nearly 11,000 this year. Devers and other midwives have asked the health department to let them carry the vaccine, but lawmakers would have to make that change.
The outbreak is serious: the state reported 97 infections among pregnant women and 1,505 measles cases overall as of Wednesday, with more than a third in Lancaster County. Devers says she has seen clients suffer and described a pregnancy loss after a woman became ill. The experience prompted her to reconsider the vaccine skepticism she once held.
The numbers also show why the debate needs more than a single talking point. Lancaster County’s kindergarten vaccination rate was 87.6% last school year, below its 95.5% pre-pandemic level, and 75% of U.S. jurisdictions with data were below the measles herd-immunity threshold. Some doctors say natural immunity may have protected mothers and newborns in the past; pediatricians also note congenital measles was uncommon when most mothers had been infected as children. The immediate challenge is reaching families with credible advice and access to vaccination.
Reported by The Daily Caller, NBC News.






