Stewart’s Bat Leads Rookie Race, but Wetherholt and Benge Offer More

Stewart’s power production has made him the apparent front-runner for the National League’s top rookie honor, with the winner expected to be announced on November 9. The 22-year-old drove in 113 runs and hit 32 homers, the second-highest total by a Reds rookie. He also ranked among qualified rookies’ top 10 in several categories, including doubles, walks and slugging percentage.

His offense was less impressive when weighed against his work on the bases and in the field. Statcast rated his batting run value at plus-14, but his baserunning and fielding values were each minus-4. His 2.0 wins above replacement, measured by fWAR, placed him well behind the other finalists.

Wetherholt led National League rookies with 4.6 fWAR, combining strong hitting discipline and baserunning with elite defense at second base. He ranked first in fielding run value and recorded 25 outs above average. The report also noted he received no Gold Glove, despite committing only two errors.

Benge finished close behind Wetherholt at 4.3 fWAR. He hit 20 home runs and stole 22 bases, becoming the 18th player in major-league history to reach 20 homers and 20 steals as a rookie. His defense in right field was also a strength: he led the National League with 10 outfield assists. Stewart’s eye-catching run totals may prevail, but the comparison favors the other finalists in overall contributions.