Trump’s Lawsuit Record Undercuts His Bid to Revive Clinton Case
Clinton’s lawyers are asking the Supreme Court to leave in place the dismissal of Trump’s lawsuit accusing her and others of coordinating to promote an untrue narrative about ties between his 2016 campaign and Russia. Their filing argues that Trump’s own history of suing while president weakens his explanation for waiting until 2022 to bring the case.
Trump’s Own Lawsuits Weaken His Bid to Reopen Clinton Case
Trump wants the Supreme Court to revive a lawsuit accusing Hillary Clinton and others of coordinating to promote an untrue account of his campaign’s ties to Russia. But Clinton’s lawyers say his own record makes his excuse for waiting until 2022 difficult to accept: he filed other personal lawsuits during both presidential terms.
The cases they point to include a dispute about his financial documents during his initial presidency, along with libel suits in his second. That history, they argue, shows that bringing civil cases did not prevent Trump from carrying out presidential duties.
A federal judge in Florida dismissed the Clinton case, and an appellate court affirmed the ruling. The appeals court also relied on a 1997 Supreme Court ruling that President Bill Clinton could not avoid civil proceedings while in office. Its reasoning was that a president who can be required to answer a lawsuit can also pursue his own legal claims.
Trump’s lawyers argue that being sued and choosing to sue are different, and that he deferred private litigation to focus on his constitutional responsibilities. Clinton’s lawyers counter that the case fails not only because of its timing but also on its merits. The Supreme Court has asked Clinton to respond after Trump’s lawyers initially waived a response; that request alone does not establish that the justices will take up the case.
Supreme Court Should Not Spend Its Time on Trump’s Clinton Suit
The Supreme Court should leave intact the dismissal of Trump’s lawsuit against Hillary Clinton and others. The case, filed in 2022 over alleged efforts to link his 2016 campaign to Russia, has already been rejected by a federal judge and an appeals court—and Clinton’s lawyers say it does not merit the justices’ limited time.
Trump argues that the workload during his initial presidency prevented him from filing suit sooner. Clinton’s lawyers answer with a straightforward contradiction: he brought personal lawsuits while serving as president, including a first-term case over his financial records and defamation actions during his second term.
That history challenges the claim that presidential responsibilities prevented him from pursuing his own legal rights. The appeals court also cited the Supreme Court’s 1997 ruling that President Bill Clinton could not avoid civil litigation while in office, reasoning that a president able to be sued is not excused from bringing a suit of his own.
Trump’s lawyers say the two situations are different and that he chose to prioritize his constitutional duties. But the case faces more than a timing problem: Clinton’s lawyers contend that the claims fail on their merits as well. The justices asked Clinton to respond after Trump’s lawyers initially waived a response, a step that does not itself signal enough support to hear the case.







