Judge Approves Exton Square Redevelopment as Township Plans Appeal
On November 13, Chester County Judge Sarah Black overturned West Whiteland Township’s rejection of Abrams Realty & Development’s plan to replace most of the closed Exton Square Mall with homes, shops and other uses. Township supervisors said on November 16 that they intend to appeal, keeping the dispute over the 75-acre property alive after an 11-month legal fight.
The supervisors had cited concerns about the project’s scale, traffic, sewer capacity and demands on emergency services. The developer argued its proposal met the zoning rules in force when it applied. Black found the township had not supplied substantial evidence that the plan would harm the community and said officials had applied an unfairly demanding standard.
Abrams’ proposal includes 172 townhouses, 381 apartments and 165 homes for older adults, as well as commercial, office, fitness and entertainment space. The Boscov’s store would remain, and Main Line Health would continue operating at the site. The mall, which opened 53 years ago, closed in June.
Supervisor Brian Dunn said the board plans to pursue an appeal. Vice Chair Rajesh Kumbhardare said the township is reviewing the ruling and would continue to defend residents’ interests. Peter Abrams, the developer’s CEO, welcomed the decision and said demolition could begin by early summer. Further litigation could delay the project.
Court Clears Path for Homes as Township’s Density Fight Continues
On November 13, a Chester County judge overturned West Whiteland Township’s rejection of Abrams Realty & Development’s proposal for the Exton Square Mall site. The ruling allows a plan with 718 homes to proceed, even as township supervisors say they will appeal and continue contesting the project’s scale.
The developer’s proposal includes apartments, townhouses and homes for older adults, alongside shops, offices and entertainment space. The mall closed in June after 53 years. Boscov’s would remain at the redeveloped site, as would Main Line Health.
Township officials raised concerns about traffic, sewer capacity and pressure on emergency services. But Judge Sarah Black found the township had not produced substantial evidence that the project would be harmful and concluded that officials had held the developer to an overly demanding standard. That ruling puts the burden on local leaders to justify blocking a plan that the court found consistent with the applicable zoning.
Supervisor Brian Dunn said on November 16 that the township intends to appeal. Vice Chair Rajesh Kumbhardare said officials are reviewing the decision and will continue to advocate for residents. Developer Peter Abrams welcomed the ruling, and said demolition could begin by early summer. Any further court fight could still hold up construction.
Judge Sides With Developer Over Township’s Community Concerns
A judge has cleared Abrams Realty & Development to pursue a sweeping redevelopment of the closed Exton Square Mall, overruling local officials who warned about density and strain on public services. On November 13, Chester County Judge Sarah Black reversed West Whiteland Township’s denial; supervisors said on November 16 they would appeal.
The plan calls for 718 homes, commercial and office space, and fitness and entertainment uses. It would keep Boscov’s at the site and preserve Main Line Health’s presence. The mall closed in June after 53 years.
Township leaders had pointed to traffic, sewer capacity and the demands a larger population could place on police and emergency services. They also updated zoning rules last year to limit housing density in the district. Black found that the township had not backed its rejection with substantial evidence and said it had demanded too much of the developer.
That decision leaves residents’ concerns competing with a court-approved project on a 75-acre site near busy Routes 30 and 100. Supervisor Brian Dunn said the board intends to appeal, while Vice Chair Rajesh Kumbhardare said officials are assessing their next steps. Developer Peter Abrams said demolition could start by early summer, though additional litigation could delay the work.
Reported by The Philadelphia Inquirer, PhillyVoice.






