Judge Overturns Anthony Garrett’s Murder Conviction
Cook County Circuit Judge Adrienne E. Davis threw out Anthony Garrett’s murder conviction and sentence on November 16, ruling that his handwritten confession in the 1992 killing of 7-year-old Dantrell Davis was more likely than not obtained through torture. She suppressed the confession and ordered a new trial. Garrett was transferred from state prison to Cook County Jail, and a hearing was set for December 7 on a possible prosecution appeal and whether he will remain detained.
Davis reached her decision after a months-long evidentiary hearing. Garrett’s lawyers asserted that former Chicago police investigator Richard Zuley arranged for Garrett to be beaten while shackled to an eyebolt. They connected the claim to allegations of coercion in other cases involving Zuley and to testimony about his work at the U.S. detention facility at Guantánamo Bay. Prosecutors urged the judge to disregard allegations from other cases, arguing they did not establish what happened to Garrett.
Zuley denied knowing of any abuse and testified that he left other detectives in charge overnight. He said Garrett confessed the next morning to shooting at rival gang members, then signed a handwritten statement. Prosecutors also questioned Garrett’s account of the beating, including how his description changed over time, and cited testimony that he did not appear injured afterward. Davis’s ruling sets the case on course for a retrial. Garrett, now 68, was convicted by a jury in 1994 and sentenced to 100 years; he had been scheduled for release in 2039.
Judge Rejects Confession Tied to Alleged Police Torture
A judge has rejected a murder conviction after finding that the confession at its center was more likely than not produced by torture. On November 16, Cook County Circuit Judge Adrienne E. Davis threw out Anthony Garrett’s conviction and sentence, suppressed his handwritten statement and ordered a new trial.
Garrett’s lawyers said retired Chicago detective Richard Zuley arranged a beating while Garrett was shackled to an eyebolt. They pointed to allegations of coercion in other cases involving Zuley and testimony about his role at Guantánamo Bay. The prosecution argued those other allegations had no connection to Garrett, and challenged details in his account of the beating. Zuley denied knowing of abuse and said Garrett confessed after other detectives questioned him overnight.
The ruling underscores the stakes when a conviction depends on a confession whose reliability is in dispute. Garrett was convicted by a jury in 1994 and sentenced to 100 years. The judge ordered his transfer to Cook County Jail and scheduled a December 7 hearing on a possible prosecution appeal and his detention status. The case is now set for a retrial, while the state may seek to challenge the ruling.
Judge Tosses Murder Conviction Despite Prosecutors’ Challenge
A Cook County judge has set aside a jury’s murder conviction after deciding that Anthony Garrett was more likely than not tortured into confessing. Judge Adrienne E. Davis suppressed Garrett’s handwritten statement on November 16 and ordered a new trial, despite prosecutors’ arguments that claims about retired detective Richard Zuley’s conduct in other cases had no connection to Garrett.
The prosecution challenged Garrett’s account of being beaten while shackled, noting that his description changed and pointing to testimony that he did not appear injured afterward. Zuley denied knowing of any physical or mental abuse and testified that Garrett confessed the morning after other detectives questioned him overnight. Garrett’s lawyers, by contrast, argued Zuley coordinated the abuse and cited allegations from other cases as well as testimony concerning his work at Guantánamo Bay.
The ruling leaves the state to decide whether to appeal as Garrett awaits a retrial. Davis scheduled a December 7 hearing on a possible appeal and Garrett’s detention status, and ordered his transfer from state prison to Cook County Jail. Garrett was convicted by a jury in 1994 and sentenced to 100 years. The decision now puts the disputed confession—and the evidence behind it—at the center of the next stage of the case.
Reported by Chicago Sun-Times, CBS Chicago.






