Jess Carter Set to Join Bay FC in Free Agency
Jess Carter is set to join Bay FC as a free agent, leaving Gotham FC after the club’s 2026 season ended in the NWSL semifinals. Gotham lost to Kansas City Current on November 15 at Icahn Stadium on Randall’s Island, missing the chance to win consecutive championships and a third title in four seasons.
Carter, 29, moved to Gotham from Chelsea in 2024. She played 30 matches across all competitions this season and made 62 NWSL starts over her time with the club, featuring at center back and right back. Gotham won the 2025 championship and the 2026 Shield during her tenure.
After the semifinal defeat, Carter described her two and a half years at Gotham as excellent and praised the people at the club. Her move would bring experience to a Bay team that finished 14th in the 2026 standings, with the league’s third-worst goal difference, and missed the playoffs. Bay is also losing seasoned back-line players Emily Menges, Abby Dahlkemper and Caprice Dydasco.
Goalkeeper Ann-Katrin Berger is also set to leave Gotham in free agency. She joined from Chelsea in 2024, earned the league’s top goalkeeper honor in her debut season and is nominated again for 2026 after recording 11 clean sheets. Gotham conceded a league-low 23 goals this season. Backup goalkeeper Shelby Hogan is also a free agent.
Carter is aiming to play for England at next summer’s World Cup. Gotham’s signed center backs include Tierna Davidson and Emily Sonnett; Sonnett missed the second half of the season after knee surgery. Midge Purce is among the club’s other free agents.
Reported by Sports Illustrated, New York Post.







