Close ✕
Crime U.S.
Photo: WSVN 7News

Clancy Returns to Court as Prosecutors Weigh Retrial

The hearing comes after a jury failed to reach a unanimous verdict in September on three first-degree murder charges against Clancy. Prosecutors have not publicly confirmed whether they will pursue a second trial. Plymouth County District Attorney Timothy Cruz has said he planned to make a decision by the hearing, while emphasizing that the office is seeking justice for the children.

Clancy’s defense acknowledged that she killed her children but argued she was not criminally responsible because she was experiencing postpartum psychosis. After more than 38 hours of deliberations, the jury remained divided 11 to one, and the judge declared a mistrial. Jurors could also consider second-degree murder and manslaughter.

Judge William Sullivan has rejected the defense’s request to drop the charges under double-jeopardy rules. He has urged the parties to set a date for a possible retrial and raised March as an option, though the schedule could change. A criminal justice professor said the hearing would indicate whether prosecutors intend to continue the case, but that decisions could still shift before trial.

The sole juror who opposed finding Clancy not criminally responsible, Michael Desronvil, faced public scrutiny after the mistrial. His lawyer says he was doxxed, people came to his home and he changed his work schedule because of the attention. The judge also denied a defense request for an inquiry into Desronvil’s conduct. His attorney says the experience has led him to consider studying law.

Reported by CNN, Daily Mail US, CBS Boston.

How the story went

Related stories

Top stories now

About