Hegseth survives first impeachment push as Democrats signal another
Republican Representative Thomas Massie’s eight articles accused Hegseth of misconduct related to the Iran war, deadly strikes on alleged drug-trafficking boats, the seizure of former Venezuelan president Nicolas Maduro and efforts to retaliate against Democratic Senator Mark Kelly. The House rejected a motion to send the articles to a committee, 211-204. Eleven absent Democrats could have changed the result if they had voted, the account said; some cited traffic as the reason for their absence.
The vote came amid criticism of Hegseth’s conduct at Arlington National Cemetery during a Veterans’ Day visit on Wednesday. A sentinel reprimanded him and his party after they spoke and laughed loudly near the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier.
Hegseth dismissed the impeachment effort as a political stunt during his first Pentagon media briefing in half a year, saying it gave US adversaries a propaganda victory. Critics, including veterans and former military officials, said the charges deserve a fuller examination. They have accused him of incompetence, unlawful killings in the boat strikes and rhetoric that could encourage war crimes. Hegseth has said the people killed in the strikes were drug traffickers involved in narco-terrorism, without providing evidence, the account said.
Critics also pointed to a strike on a girls’ school in Minab, Iran, that killed more than 165 people, including 120 children, on the first day of the war in February. The United States has not accepted responsibility; independent investigations cited in the account concluded it was a US strike.
Democratic leader Hakeem Jeffries, expected to become House speaker in January, vowed to remove Hegseth. Supporters of impeachment expect Democrats to develop the case further when the new Congress convenes. Removing Hegseth would require a two-thirds vote in a Senate trial; Democrats are expected to hold at most 56 Senate seats, with Alaska’s race still undecided.
Hegseth’s failed impeachment reprieve may not last
Pete Hegseth escaped an immediate impeachment inquiry by just seven votes, as the House rejected advancing eight articles against him, 211-204. The articles raise grave questions about his role in the Iran war, lethal boat strikes and alleged retaliation against Senator Mark Kelly. The next Congress should not treat that narrow procedural victory as an answer to the charges.
The allegations reach beyond partisan combat. Critics say the boat attacks, which have killed around 200 people, were unlawful killings, and that Hegseth’s language on rules of engagement risks enabling war crimes. A strike on a girls’ school in Minab killed more than 165 people, including 120 children. The United States has not acknowledged responsibility, while independent investigations cited in the account concluded it was a US strike.
Hegseth called the impeachment effort a political stunt. But veterans and former military officials argue that the scale of the allegations demands scrutiny, not dismissal. One former National Guard general predicted Hegseth would be impeached once the new Congress is seated; Jeffries, expected to become speaker in January, has also vowed to push him out.
The House vote was only a decision not to send the articles to committee. Democrats are expected to pursue a more rigorous process in the next Congress. Conviction and removal would require two-thirds of the Senate, a steep threshold, but the charges and the deaths at issue make accountability a matter of public consequence.
Hegseth impeachment push stalls as critics prepare another fight
The House declined to advance eight impeachment articles against Pete Hegseth, voting 211-204 against sending them to a committee. The result checked an effort by Republican Thomas Massie and Democrats to turn disputes over the Iran war and military operations into an impeachment campaign.
Hegseth called the move a political stunt that handed US adversaries a propaganda win. That argument deserves attention: the articles bundle accusations over the Iran war, boat strikes, the seizure of former Venezuelan president Nicolas Maduro and alleged retaliation against Senator Mark Kelly into a push to remove a cabinet secretary. The House has not approved an inquiry, much less established the claims.
Democrats are already promising to try again. Hakeem Jeffries, expected to become speaker in January, vowed to run Hegseth out of office, while veterans’ advocates say impeachment has broad support in their community. That renewed effort will come with the same unresolved political hurdle: conviction in a Senate trial requires two-thirds of senators, while Democrats are expected to hold at most 56 seats.
The debate has also unfolded amid criticism of Hegseth’s handling of the Iran war and deadly strikes on boats alleged to carry drugs. Those remain accusations in the impeachment case; Hegseth has described the people targeted as drug traffickers engaged in narco-terrorism. The House vote shows that, for now, opponents have not secured the support to move their case forward.
Reported by The Guardian, The Washington Examiner, Daily Kos.








