Marte Could Cost Toronto $87.5 Million and Young Talent

Toronto needs more offense after finishing last in the majors in 2026 in runs, home runs and isolated power. The Blue Jays scored 648 runs and hit 152 home runs, a sharp decline from the 798 runs and 191 homers they produced in 2025.

Marte could bring power from both sides of the plate, but his 2026 season was a downturn. His 2.5 WAR was well below his 5.1 average over the prior three seasons, and his wRC+ fell to 103 after marks of 152 and 146. His .316 on-base percentage and .257 batting average on balls in play were career lows in qualified seasons.

The 33-year-old still ranks among the most productive second basemen since 2024, with 13.5 fWAR, a .500 slugging percentage, 243 RBIs and a 133 wRC+. He hit 36 home runs in 2024 and 28 in 2025. A move to Toronto could offer a middle-of-the-order bat, though the price would be significant.

Arizona has reason to consider a deal after finishing 86-76 and missing the playoffs. The Diamondbacks have identified left-handed power and pitching as offseason needs, while owner Ken Kendrick has said the team’s 2027 budget will shrink after its record payroll in 2026. Moving Marte could also free salary and bring back young players.

Toronto previously explored Marte, but Arizona sought controllable starting pitchers. A new deal could involve Blue Jays hitter Addison Barger, a left-handed bat who may fit in the outfield or at an infield corner. Toronto would also take on $76 million in salaries from 2027 through 2030, or $87.5 million if Marte exercises his 2031 option.