SAG-AFTRA Chief Says Most Performers Want AI Misuses Removed
Duncan Crabtree-Ireland, the head of SAG-AFTRA, said more than 90% of cases involving unauthorized AI use of performers’ likenesses are about stopping the use, rather than pursuing financial damages. He spoke during a Web Summit discussion in Lisbon on November 12, where he said people object when their image or voice is used without permission and want the content removed.
Crabtree-Ireland backed the proposed NO FAKES Act, which is intended to give people greater control over digital copies of their voices and likenesses. He said the legislation could help platforms remove material that uses a person’s identity without consent.
He estimated that 10% to 15% of SAG-AFTRA’s 160,000 members want artificial intelligence blocked altogether. Others, he said, are willing to use AI to support their work, but do not want it to replace them. He described consent, control and compensation as key principles for AI use in entertainment.
Crabtree-Ireland also argued that AI-generated characters should be distinguished from real people, saying synthetic creations do not have human lives or experiences. He recalled that his own likeness had been misused during the 2023 actors’ strike.
Dan Neely, CEO of AI licensing company Vermillio, said its tools can identify unauthorized uses and set conditions for permitted ones. He said identifying how much a generated voice or image draws on particular people can be difficult, and expected greater clarity on that issue over the next year.
Performers Want Control Over AI Copies, Not a Payday
The central demand from performers facing AI misuse is straightforward: stop using their identities without permission. SAG-AFTRA chief Duncan Crabtree-Ireland said more than 90% of such cases are about getting content taken down, not collecting damages. He made the remarks at Web Summit in Lisbon on November 12.
Crabtree-Ireland supported the proposed NO FAKES Act as a way to give people a say over digital versions of their voices and likenesses. His position underscores the stakes for workers whose identities can help draw audiences to AI-generated material. The issue is not simply whether a new tool exists, but whether performers retain consent and control over their own image and voice.
He estimated that 10% to 15% of SAG-AFTRA’s 160,000 members would prefer AI to be blocked altogether. Others want tools that help them create, not systems that replace them. Crabtree-Ireland identified consent, control and compensation as basic conditions for AI’s use in entertainment.
Dan Neely of Vermillio described technology for detecting unauthorized uses and setting limits on approved ones. Crabtree-Ireland also backed distinguishing actual people from synthetic characters, and recalled his own likeness being misused during the 2023 strike.
SAG-AFTRA Chief Accepts AI Is Here, Seeks Rules for Its Use
Artificial intelligence is not going away, SAG-AFTRA chief Duncan Crabtree-Ireland told attendees at the Lisbon Web Summit on November 12. He estimated that 10% to 15% of the union’s 160,000 members want it blocked, while others want to use AI tools to expand their creative work rather than be replaced.
Crabtree-Ireland said more than 90% of performers seeking a remedy for unauthorized AI replicas want the material removed, not damages. He backed the proposed NO FAKES Act as a way to give people greater authority over digital copies of their voices and likenesses. His argument focuses on consent and takedowns, rather than treating every dispute as a fight for compensation.
He said AI use in entertainment should involve consent, control and compensation, and argued that synthetic characters should not be confused with real people. He also recalled his own likeness being misused during the 2023 actors’ strike.
Dan Neely, CEO of Vermillio, said his company can detect unauthorized uses and provide guardrails for uses that are permitted. He also pointed to the difficulty of measuring how much a generated voice or image draws on different people, with greater clarity on that issue expected over the coming year.
Reported by The Hollywood Reporter, Deadline.






