Democrats Propose New Limits on Presidential Pardons
The Abuse of the Pardon Prevention Act would task the Justice Department’s internal watchdog with examining clemency grants that may involve competing interests. Its sponsors say the measure responds to concerns that wealthy defendants can use well-connected lawyers and lobbyists to seek clemency from President Donald Trump. About 70% of Trump’s clemency decisions in his second presidency have gone around the Justice Department’s pardon office.
The bill would also make explicit that a president or vice president could face prosecution for trading a pardon for something of value. It would require recipients to disclose gifts to projects connected to the president, among them his presidential library or planned White House ballroom, while prohibiting presidential self-pardons.
Levin, a California Democrat, said the pardon power should serve justice and mercy, not be available to the highest bidder. Crow, a Colorado Democrat, argued that abuse of clemency could create a two-tiered justice system favoring wealthy and well-connected people. Levin said his concerns also encompass pardons issued during the Biden and Clinton presidencies.
Trump’s legal adviser, Will Scharf, dismissed accusations of improper behavior, saying Trump exercises his constitutional duties ethically and that the administration has a review process involving White House and Justice Department officials. Trump has the final say in that process, Scharf said.
The bill faces both a likely presidential veto and constitutional objections. Former Justice Department pardon adviser Samuel Morison said legislation cannot regulate the president’s pardon power, while legal scholars Josh Blackman and Brian Kalt also questioned key provisions. Kalt called the self-pardon ban symbolic; Levin countered that Congress could use its spending power to support independent investigations.
Congress Must Check a Pardon System Favoring the Powerful
Democratic Reps. Mike Levin and Jason Crow are pressing for oversight of President Donald Trump’s use of clemency, introducing the Abuse of the Pardon Prevention Act on November 11. Their proposal would direct the Justice Department inspector general to investigate pardons involving possible conflicts of interest, amid concerns that wealthy defendants have enlisted Trump-connected lawyers and lobbyists to pursue clemency. About 70% of Trump’s clemency decisions during his second presidency went around the department’s pardon office.
The bill would make it explicit that a president or vice president could be prosecuted for exchanging a pardon for something of value. It would also make clemency beneficiaries report contributions to ventures connected to the president and prohibit self-pardons.
Levin says clemency is meant to serve justice and mercy, not become a route to special treatment. Crow warns that a system favoring the wealthy and well-connected undermines equal justice. Levin has also criticized pardons issued under earlier Democratic presidents, arguing that reform should protect the institution rather than one party.
The White House denies wrongdoing and says Trump’s decisions are ethically made after a review involving White House and Justice Department officials. But that process leaves Trump as the final decision-maker.
Legal challenges are possible, with former Justice Department pardon adviser Samuel Morison saying Congress cannot regulate the president’s pardon power through legislation. That constitutional objection deserves scrutiny, but it does not erase the lawmakers’ concern: a clemency system vulnerable to conflicts can weaken public confidence in equal treatment under the law. Levin says Congress can use its spending power to support independent investigations.
Democrats’ Pardon Bill Risks Crossing Constitutional Lines
Democratic Reps. Mike Levin and Jason Crow introduced a bill on November 11 that would subject some presidential pardons to inspector general investigations and impose new restrictions on clemency. The proposal comes as the White House says President Donald Trump’s pardon decisions undergo review by White House and Justice Department officials, with the president making the final decision.
The Abuse of the Pardon Prevention Act would authorize investigations into pardons raising possible conflicts of interest, make explicit that presidents and vice presidents could be prosecuted for trading clemency for something valuable, require disclosure of gifts to projects connected to the president, and bar self-pardons. Supporters say the measures would guard against favoritism. But the bill’s reach raises a fundamental question: whether Congress can legislate limits on a power granted to the president by the Constitution.
Former Justice Department pardon adviser Samuel Morison said misuse of the power is addressed through impeachment and removal, not legislation regulating its exercise. Legal scholar Brian Kalt said the proposed self-pardon ban would change nothing if the president lacks that power and could not remove it if he has it. Josh Blackman also warned the bill’s broad conflict-of-interest standard could expose controversial pardons to criminal investigations.
The White House rejects claims that Trump acts unethically and says allegations to that effect are ill-informed or malicious. The legislation faces a likely veto as well as substantial constitutional objections. Levin argues Congress can act through its spending power to ensure independent investigations, but that claim does not settle whether lawmakers may impose the proposed limits on presidential clemency.
Reported by CBS News, Raw Story.







