Emails Reveal ICE Agent’s Racist Attacks on Sister’s Colombian Partner
Emails from 2021 show David Brouillette attacking his sister Elizabeth Emen’s Colombian partner, a university student who legally resided in the United States. Brouillette wrote that the man should return to his “third world” country and disparaged his background and his claim to American values. Emen shared the messages with family members and said her brother’s words were about her partner’s race, not his immigration status.
Emen explained that the argument started when she invited relatives to her son’s birthday. Brouillette condemned her relationship and told her she had lost him as a brother. His mother, Susan Bedard, told The New York Times that he was dangerous and should not have weapons, and urged people to believe his victims.
In July, Brouillette fatally shot 25-year-old Johan Sebastian Duran Guerrero as he tried to make a traffic stop in Biddeford. Guerrero was driving to work with his wife and young daughter nearby. According to his family’s attorney, Guerrero had work authorization in the United States and was not the person ICE was investigating. ICE later acknowledged its warrant named another individual, according to the second report.
The Department of Homeland Security said Guerrero’s vehicle tried to flee and that Brouillette fired because he feared for public safety. No evidence supporting that account has emerged. The shooting is under investigation, and the emails may be relevant to an excessive-force argument, former federal prosecutor Michael Gennaco said. He noted that racial animus need not be proved under federal law but could support such an argument.
ICE Agent’s Racist Emails Deepen Questions About Fatal Shooting
The emails point to a troubling record of racial hostility behind an ICE agent’s use of lethal force. In 2021, David Brouillette told his sister Elizabeth Emen that her Colombian partner should return to a “third world” country and attacked his background and belonging in America. Emen said his accusations were rooted in race, not immigration status.
Four years afterward, Brouillette killed 25-year-old Johan Sebastian Duran Guerrero while attempting a traffic stop in Biddeford. Guerrero was on his way to work. His family’s attorney said Guerrero had authorization to work in the United States and was not the person ICE was investigating. The agency later acknowledged its warrant named another individual, according to the reports.
DHS said Guerrero’s vehicle tried to flee and that Brouillette fired out of concern for public safety, but evidence backing that account has not emerged. The shooting is under investigation. Former federal prosecutor Michael Gennaco said the emails could help support an excessive-force argument, even though prosecutors do not have to prove racial animus under federal law.
The case also raises questions about the agency’s hiring standards. An account says ICE relaxed vetting as it sought to expand deportations, allowing unqualified applicants to join. The emails and the fatal shooting make those choices—and the consequences of unchecked hostility within law enforcement—harder to dismiss.
Shooting Investigation Must Weigh Evidence, Not Emails Alone
The investigation into Johan Sebastian Duran Guerrero’s death should establish what happened during the July traffic stop, while also examining the newly surfaced emails. ICE agent David Brouillette wrote racist insults about his sister’s Colombian partner in 2021. Those messages are disturbing, but they are not by themselves a complete account of the shooting.
DHS said Guerrero’s vehicle attempted to flee and that Brouillette fired because he feared for public safety. No evidence substantiating that explanation has emerged. ICE also acknowledged that its warrant named someone else, and Guerrero was not the target of the investigation. Those facts warrant scrutiny alongside the agency’s account.
Guerrero, 25, was driving to work when he was shot in Biddeford, Maine. His family’s attorney said Guerrero had work authorization in the United States. Brouillette’s sister, Elizabeth Emen, said his earlier attacks on her partner were about race rather than immigration status. His mother said he was dangerous and should not have weapons.
The shooting remains under investigation. Former federal prosecutor Michael Gennaco said the emails could support an argument that excessive force was used, though racial animus is not required for a federal prosecution. The findings should turn on the evidence from the stop, with the emails considered as relevant context rather than treated as a verdict on their own.
Reported by The Daily Beast, The New Republic, The Boston Globe, Raw Story, ABC7 New York, MSNBC, Reason.







