Privy Council Strikes Down Trinidad and Tobago’s Gay Sex Ban
The Judicial Committee of the Privy Council, Trinidad and Tobago’s highest appeals court, struck down the country’s ban on gay sexual acts on November 10. The unanimous ruling is final and cannot be appealed, ending a legal battle begun by LGBTQ+ rights activist Jason Jones in 2017.
The laws carry prison sentences of up to five years for “buggery” and two years for gross indecency. They date to measures introduced under British colonial rule and were revised in 1986. Although they have not been enforced in recent history, critics say their continued presence stigmatizes gay people.
Judge Philip James Sales said the laws could not be justified in a society that respects individual rights and freedoms. The court found that private, consensual sexual activity between adults is protected by the guarantee of privacy in personal and family life.
Jones first won a constitutional challenge in Trinidad and Tobago’s High Court in 2018. The Court of Appeal reversed that decision in 2025, and the government sought to preserve the appeals court’s ruling. Jones argued that the revised laws were not shielded from challenge by a constitutional provision protecting some pre-independence laws.
The decision applies to Trinidad and Tobago, but campaigners and legal experts say it could influence challenges elsewhere. Jamaica, Grenada and Saint Vincent and the Grenadines retain similar bans. Several former British colonies still rely on the Privy Council to hear their last appeals, while Trinidad and Tobago has also pushed to replace it with the Caribbean Court of Justice.
Privy Council Ends Trinidad and Tobago’s Discriminatory Gay Sex Ban
Trinidad and Tobago’s colonial-era ban on gay sexual acts is unconstitutional, the Privy Council ruled on November 10. The unanimous decision ends a nearly decade-long fight led by LGBTQ+ rights activist Jason Jones and affirms that private, consensual intimacy is part of individual freedom.
The laws allowed sentences of as many as five years for “buggery” and two years for gross indecency. Though not enforced in recent history, they remained on the books and, critics say, sent a stigmatizing message. The court said criminalizing private sexual activity between consenting adults could not be justified in a society that respects individual rights.
Jones challenged the laws in 2017 and won in the High Court in 2018. A local appeals court reversed that result in 2025, while the government sought to uphold that ruling. The Privy Council’s final judgment now rejects the legal framework that kept the ban in place.
The ruling applies only in Trinidad and Tobago, but it may strengthen challenges in other former British colonies. Jamaica, Grenada and Saint Vincent and the Grenadines still have similar bans. The case also underscores the impact of colonial-era laws that continue to restrict people’s rights decades after independence.
Final Court Rejects Trinidad and Tobago’s Gay Sex Ban
The Privy Council has struck down Trinidad and Tobago’s laws criminalizing gay sexual acts, issuing a final ruling on November 10. The unanimous judgment ends Jason Jones’ legal challenge and rejects the government’s position that the ban should remain in force.
The laws set maximum prison terms of five years for “buggery” and two years for gross indecency. The dispute also concerned a constitutional provision that protects some laws dating from before independence from legal challenges. A local appeals court had ruled in 2025 that the High Court erred when it invalidated the laws, and the government asked the Privy Council to uphold that outcome.
Instead, Judge Philip James Sales said private sexual activity between consenting adults could not be criminalized consistently with respect for individual rights and freedoms. The ruling is final and cannot be appealed.
The decision applies to Trinidad and Tobago, but activists and legal experts say it could shape similar cases in former British colonies. Jamaica, Grenada and Saint Vincent and the Grenadines retain comparable bans. The case also highlights a question for countries that still rely on the London-based Privy Council as their highest appeals court: whether that role should pass to the Caribbean Court of Justice.







